Questioning Democracy with Masha Gessen, Paul Ham and David Runciman

In line with the shocking theme of the Festival of Dangerous Ideas 2024 (FODI), I attended the aptly named talk Democracy is Not Worth Dying For on a wintry Sunday morning. 

Source: Jessica Han

Geraldine Doogue, an Australian journalist and presenter for the ABC, chaired the talk between three speakers with varying backgrounds: Russian-American political journalist Masha Gessen, Australian historian Paul Ham and British podcaster David Runciman.

The auditorium I entered was drenched in intense red light, which stayed on throughout the talk. It felt as if the audience was a sea of blood; perhaps as a purposefully bleak omen for our potential future. A question rises in the air: is democracy worth dying for? 

 

What is democracy? 

Democracy is “a system of government by the whole population or all the eligible members of a state, typically through elected representatives” according to Oxford Languages. A single word encompasses an extensive history of complex human politics, with democracy having been implemented in countless ways throughout the world. This makes it difficult to make a clear-cut boundary on what democracy is.  

Democracy is also arguably unattainable. Humans have created institutions like the government, the judiciary and the police to enforce a democracy, but a truly equal system is impossible. This doubly makes any judgement on democracy difficult. 

The voters within a democracy also make a huge difference. Often policies that are favoured by the population are not the most economically optimal, especially to enforce equality and justice. Runciman commented that complacency, corruption, bribery and ignorance are sabotages to democracy. 

 

Is there anything really worth dying for? 

Gessen shared that they chose to leave Russia when under threat of the Russian government, unlike other Russian activists that fought for democracy in prisons and martyrdom. Gessen expressed that the only thing they might die for is their children, which is a stance that many people would feel similar towards. 

 

Well then, is democracy any good? 

Doogue started the conversation with Michelle Obama’s speech that had occurred earlier that week, where Michelle called upon the American people to utilise democracy to create the future that they need. The speech was inspiring and optimistic about the changes that could be made through the existing system of democracy. This view is a requirement for the continuation of democracies around the world – the idea that as individuals, we have power to influence our future. 

On the other hand, Runciman, who had co-founded a research institute at Cambridge for the purpose of analysing democracy, had many criticisms.  He emphasised that democracy relies on archaic conventions.  

Despite our rapidly evolving culture and technology, our politics have remained largely the same as it was when our governments were first established. In the same way that the language of the past is inadequate for interpreting the rules for the present, our institutions may become obsolete in the future.  

The recent wavering trust in institutions is obvious in places like the United States (US), with ongoing conflicts regarding the legitimacy of the police and judiciary. Runciman noted a trend in the de-conversion of world democracies, a stark downward trend compared to the boom of democracies that followed the second World War. He recalled a parallel to the 1930s, when a massive recession preceded the rise of autocracies. 

Overall, Runciman expressed his scepticism in the future of democracy. The people who fought to instate the democracies we have lived in for centuries had very different lifestyles and priorities to people now – refer to Gessen’s point above: is there anything really worth dying for? He stated that the existing democratic system creates an insulating divide between politics and the people they represent, which prevents people from involving themselves in a democracy in alternative ways. 

Ham combatted Runciman’s view by bringing up the importance of the principle of democracy – the mechanics may be old, but isn’t the core purpose of democracy worth fighting for? He questioned whether the criticisms of democracy were too perfectionist, thinking it was more important to focus on the potential of democracy. Even as a war historian, Ham found that optimism and hope could be found even in the darkest places. 

 

In conclusion… 

Democracy is a concept we take for granted in this modern day. We assume that it is something we have already rightly fought for, with wars and revolutions overcome and concluded, resulting in the establishment of governments meant to fairly represent us.  

“Democracy is Not Worth Dying For” prods at the validity of democracy. Paul Ham on one side of the debate promoted the philosophy behind democracy – the idea that law is made for the people and by the people, is something that is invaluable to our society. In the middle, Masha Gessen commented on their experiences with Russia and its autocratic regime, having known many outspoken figures for democracy that are now jailed or dead.  

Gessen expressed a distaste for the existing state of democracy, citing the US as a notable example, with the result of the 2016 elections creating a domino effect that has only seemingly started now.  

David Runciman on the other side of the discussion shook the idea of democracy to its core, interrogating: does democracy actually work? Is it outdated? Is it morally and economically sound? Maybe we need something new? 

The Festival of Dangerous Ideas was presented by The Ethics Centre in August 2024. Catch up on talk from over 12 years’ of FODI at the Festival of Dangerous Ideas podcast, festivalofdangerousideas.com. 

 

More on the speakers… 

Masha Gessen is a Russian-American political journalist who has written about issues concerning Russia, Palestine, Putin and Trump. They are also an advocate for LGBTQ+ rights, a stance that eventually forced Gessen to leave Russia. To know more about them visit their Twitter (now known as X) here. 

Paul Ham is an Australian historian based in Paris. He has a background in financial journalism and war history and is currently teaching narrative history in France. Know more about Ham at his website here. 

David Runciman is a British podcaster and was formerly a professor at the University of Cambridge. You can learn more about him by listening to his podcasts, Talking Politics and Past Present Future.